PSA Crossover Grading Prices Are Outrageous — $599 Just to Evaluate Your Card

PSA has introduced a new pricing structure for high-end crossover submissions, supposedly making the service more collector-friendly. The idea is simple: collectors pay a lower fee if their card fails to meet the minimum grade they requested.

There is one problem. That lower fee is $599 per card.

And if your card successfully crosses into a PSA holder, the bill climbs to $999, $1,999, $2,999, $4,999, or even $9,999 and beyond for a single card.

PSA is presenting this as a positive change because collectors no longer have to pay the full crossover price when a card doesn’t qualify. That’s fair as far as it goes. However, charging hundreds of dollars just to evaluate a card—and potentially thousands more to put it in a different holder—is still an outrageous proposition.

How PSA’s New Crossover Pricing Works

PSA’s crossover service allows collectors to submit cards already graded by another company. PSA evaluates the card while it remains in its original holder. You choose the minimum PSA grade you’re willing to accept, and the card is only removed and placed into a PSA holder if it meets that requirement.

The new pricing structure separates the charge into two parts:

  • Evaluation Fee: $599 — charged for every Premium crossover submission, whether the card crosses or not.
  • Successful Crossover Fee: An additional charge that applies only when the card meets your requested minimum grade.

If the card doesn’t qualify, it stays in its original holder and you pay the $599 evaluation fee. If it does qualify, you pay both fees.

That means the new system reduces the cost of an unsuccessful submission, but it doesn’t make a successful crossover any cheaper.

PSA’s Premium Crossover Pricing

Here is the pricing for standard card crossovers, based on the maximum insured value of the card.

Service LevelMaximum Insured ValueEvaluation FeeSuccessful Crossover FeeTotal If Successful
Premium 1$25,000$599$400$999
Premium 2$50,000$599$1,400$1,999
Premium 3$100,000$599$2,400$2,999
Premium 5$250,000$599$4,400$4,999
Premium 10$250,001+$599$9,400$9,999+

The Premium 10 price starts at $9,999 for items with a maximum insured value of $350,000 or less. Above $350,000, PSA adds $399 for every $10,000, or fraction thereof, in additional insured value.

Even at the lowest Premium level, a successful crossover costs nearly $1,000. At Premium 5, you’re spending almost $5,000 to move a card into a PSA holder.

And that’s before applicable shipping and other fees.

Autographed Cards Cost Even More

If the card has both a card grade and an autograph grade, the successful crossover fees are substantially higher.

Service LevelMaximum Insured ValueEvaluation FeeSuccessful Crossover FeeTotal If Successful
Premium 1$25,000$599$700$1,299
Premium 2$50,000$599$2,000$2,599
Premium 3$100,000$599$3,400$3,999
Premium 5$250,000$599$5,900$6,499
Premium 10$250,001+$599$12,400$12,999+

A Premium 10 card-and-autograph crossover starts at $12,999 for cards valued at $350,000 or less. The same additional insured-value charges apply above that amount.

These are extraordinary prices, even by the standards of high-end collectibles. A successful crossover at Premium 10 could cost more than many collectors’ entire collections.

What About Express, Super Express and Premier?

The new split-fee structure currently applies to Premium 1 and higher. PSA’s Express, Super Express and Premier crossover services remain under their existing pricing.

For regular card crossovers, those prices are:

Service LevelPrice Per CardMaximum Insured Value
Express$199$2,500
Super Express$349$5,000
Premier$599$10,000

For cards with an autograph grade, the corresponding prices are $269, $469 and $799.

This means the new $599 evaluation fee isn’t applied to every crossover submission. It applies to the Premium tiers, while the lower service levels continue to use their existing flat-fee structure.

Is a PSA Crossover Really Worth It?

There are legitimate reasons collectors want PSA-graded cards. PSA has strong brand recognition in the hobby, and certain cards can command a higher resale price in a PSA holder.

But that doesn’t mean every card is worth crossing over.

Consider a Premium 1 submission. If the card successfully crosses, you’re paying $999. If it doesn’t, you’re still paying $599 and getting your original holder back.

The card’s potential PSA premium needs to be substantial enough to justify that expense. Otherwise, you’re spending hundreds or thousands of dollars simply to change the label and holder.

There is also no guarantee that PSA will award the grade you’re hoping for. That’s the entire risk of a crossover submission, and it’s especially important when the evaluation fee alone is $599.

For most collectors, these prices make little financial sense unless they’re dealing with exceptionally valuable cards where the difference in resale value can justify the expense.

A Cheaper Failed Crossover Doesn’t Make This a Good Deal

To give PSA some credit, the new structure is an improvement for collectors whose cards don’t cross. Separating the evaluation fee from the successful crossover fee means they no longer pay the entire Premium price when the card fails to meet their requested grade.

However, let’s not pretend that $599 is an inexpensive consolation prize.

PSA is charging $599 to evaluate a card that another grading company has already authenticated and graded. If PSA doesn’t like the grade, the collector gets the card back in its original holder and is out $599.

If the card does cross, the cost can reach several thousand dollars.

PSA says it plans to bring this pricing structure to additional service levels in the future, but for now, the change is limited to Premium 1 and higher.

The bottom line is that PSA has made an unsuccessful crossover less expensive, but the service itself remains priced far beyond what most collectors should consider reasonable. A PSA slab may carry a premium in the marketplace, but that doesn’t mean collectors should have to pay outrageous fees just to get one.

Scroll to Top